Specialty Coffee & Ice Cream Pub · Est. 2009

The Full Menu

44 flavors of Gunther's ice cream & yogurt, the famous Brooklyn Milkshake, blended drinks, and the whole Java City® coffee bar.

Ice Cream & Yogurt · 44 flavors

Scoops

Cup or cone. Add a waffle cone or bowl for $0.75.

  • Toddler2.5 oz$3.50
  • Double Toddler$5.15
  • Single Scoop$4.35
  • Double Scoop$6.45
  • Triple Scoop$8.40
Take it home

Hand-packed & extras

  • Pint$9.45
  • Quart$12.90
  • 3-Gallon Tub$60.00
  • Waffle Cone$0.75
  • Waffle Bowl$0.75
  • Basic Cone$0.25
  • Extra Topping$0.75
  • ½ Banana$0.75
Long Island Favorites

Sundaes & banana splits

Every favorite comes with our creamy whipped cream, peanuts, and a cherry.

  • Sidewalk SundaeSingle scoop & 1 topping$5.65
  • Sundae RoyaleDouble scoop & 1 topping$7.60
  • The New York SundaeTriple scoop & 2 toppings$10.75
  • Banana Split3 scoops & 3 toppings$11.95
Specialty Blended Drinks

Shakes, smoothies & floats

Sizes: Small 16 oz · Med 20 oz · Large 24 oz.

  • The Brooklyn Milk Shake43 flavors · creamy whipped cream & choice of swirl 16oz$5.5520oz$6.1024oz$6.65Malt +$0.75Thicker +$1.55
  • Long Island SmoothieCreamy whipped cream & choice of swirl 16oz$5.5520oz$6.1024oz$6.65
  • Ebbets-Field Root Beer Float 16oz$4.9020oz$5.4024oz$6.30
  • Custom Blended Cappuccino / Mocha 16oz$4.9020oz$5.4524oz$6.35
  • Virgin Long Island Ice TeaAny specialty tea & sweetener 20oz$3.2524oz$3.95
Java City® Coffee

Espresso bar

Single · double · triple · quad. Base price shown.

  • Espresso$1.87
  • Espresso Con PannaSm · med · lg · quad$2.09
  • Cappuccino$2.65
  • Café Au Lait$2.75
  • Latte$3.03
  • Café Breve$3.14
  • Mocha Mexicano$3.30
  • Mocha (Dark)$3.50
  • Mocha (White)$3.52
  • Mocha Dark & Tan$3.52
  • Café Macchiato De Caramelo$3.52
Hot Drinks & Tea

Warm it up

Small · med · large.

  • Coffee / Hot TeaAsk for details$1.93
  • SteamerAsk for details$1.82
  • Hot ChocolateSub milk for water +$1.00$2.15
  • Mexican Hot Chocolate$2.80
  • Chai Tea Latte$2.90
Beverages

Fountain & milk

  • Fountain BeverageSmall · med · large$3.30
  • MilkSmall 8 oz / Large 12 oz$2.75

Combinations

  • The "Sideburns"8 oz milk + basic donutcombo
  • The "New York"12 oz coffee + basic donutcombo
When Available

Bakery & treats

Made fresh — ask the counter for today's pricing.

  • Premium Yogurt Parfaitask
  • Personal Pieask
  • Pie à la Modeask
  • Fresh FruitSmall / largeask
  • DonutBasic / fancyask
  • Muffinask
  • Nutty Waffle Coneask
Make it yours

Add-ons & substitutes

  • Flavor Shotadd-on
  • Soy Milksubstitute
  • Substitute Milk for Water+$1.00
  • Extra Topping$0.75
Premium Toppings · $0.75 each

Pile it on

Sliced BananaBlueberryPineappleRaspberry StrawberryChopped CherryButterscotchCaramel ChocolateHot FudgeMarshmallowWhipped Cream Gummy BearsChocolate CandyRainbow SprinklesStar Sprinkles Smucker's® SyrupsHoneyWhite ChocolateChopped Almonds Chopped WalnutsChopped Peanuts

Prices reflect the shop's posted menu and may change. Items under “When Available” are made fresh in limited batches — ask the counter for the day's selection and pricing.

← Back to home